RC Recommendation June 2026

It Used to Work and Now It Doesn't

The most important question in troubleshooting — and why "I didn't change anything" is rarely the whole story.

By Ron Colson

IT troubleshooting infographic showing system change history timeline with technician pointing to chart asking what changed between events

Click the image to view and download the full guide

The Most Important Question in Troubleshooting

One of the most common support requests I've received over the years starts something like this:

"It used to work."

"Now it doesn't."

"And I didn't change anything."

The truth is that computers rarely decide to behave differently for no reason.

Something usually changed.

The challenge is identifying what changed and whether it is related to the problem you're seeing.

The First Question I Ask

When troubleshooting, one of the most useful questions is:

"When was the last time it worked correctly?"

That answer often narrows the investigation immediately.

Was it:

  • Earlier today?
  • Yesterday?
  • Last week?
  • Before a Windows update?
  • Before changing internet providers?
  • Before moving offices?
  • Before installing new software?

The shorter the timeline, the easier it usually is to identify potential causes.

RonBot
"Modern systems are constantly changing behind the scenes — even when you're busy doing your actual job."

— RonBot

Professional man in light blue RCIT Consulting polo shirt pointing at camera, wearing jeans and watch

"I Didn't Change Anything"

Most people mean exactly what they say. They personally didn't make any changes.

Unfortunately, computers don't care who made the change.

Modern systems are constantly changing behind the scenes. A computer that worked perfectly last week may have received:

  • Windows Updates
  • Microsoft 365 Updates
  • Browser Updates
  • Printer Driver Updates
  • Security Software Updates
  • Firmware Updates
  • VPN Client Updates

...without the user actively installing anything.

In many cases, changes happen automatically while you're busy doing your actual job.

Good Troubleshooting Starts With Finding The Change

One of the reasons professional IT tools are so valuable is that they can track system changes over time.

When a problem appears, experienced technicians often start by asking:

"What changed between the last time it worked and the first time it didn't?"

That doesn't automatically identify the cause. However, it provides a very good place to start looking.

For example:

Time Event
Friday 8:00 AM Everything working normally
Friday 11:42 PM Windows Update installed
Friday 11:43 PM Printer Driver updated
Saturday 9:00 AM Computer restarted
Monday 8:15 AM User reports printing problem

Does this prove the printer driver caused the issue?

No. But it certainly deserves investigation.

Man in blue RCH polo shirt and cap holding magnifying glass and clipboard, wearing brown vest over shoulder
RonBot
"Changes leave clues. Updates leave clues. The trick is learning where to look."
— RonBot

Think Like a Detective

Troubleshooting is often less about technical expertise and more about asking good questions.

Consider:

  • What changed recently?
  • When was the last time it worked?
  • Does the issue affect everyone or only one person?
  • Does the problem happen all the time or only occasionally?
  • Is the issue occurring on one computer or multiple computers?

The answers frequently point toward the solution.

Computers Leave Clues

One of the biggest misconceptions about technology is that problems appear randomly.

While hardware failures do occur, most software and configuration issues have a cause.

Changes leave clues. Updates leave clues. New devices leave clues. Configuration changes leave clues.

The trick is learning where to look.

RC Recommendation

Before calling support, take a moment to think about what has changed since the last time things worked correctly.

You don't need to know whether the change caused the problem. You don't even need to understand what the change means.

Simply having a list of possible changes can dramatically reduce the time required to identify the issue.

The phrase "It used to work" is often the beginning of the solution.

— Ron Colson
RC IT LLC

Worked through the basics and still stuck? RC IT can help.